Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
blessitspointedlilThe waterproof version of Altra trail runner Lone Peak. It comes in both high top and regular. I believe Gaiters are available too. https://www.altrarunning.com/en-us/hike/mens-lone-peak-9-waterproof-low/AL0A85PM.html?dwvar_AL0A85PM_color=300 https://www.altrarunning.com/en-us/hike/mens-lone-peak-9-waterproof-mid/AL0A85PK.html?dwvar_AL0A85PK_color=020 These might be a thicker sole stack height than some folks desire at 25mm.
Master_Attorney7284I would try Altra Lone Peak trail running shoes. Rounded toe box will accommodate your foot shape. They make a waterproof and non-wp version. https://www.altrarunning.com/en-us/hike/mens-lone-peak-9-waterproof-low/AL0A85PM.html?dwvar_AL0A85PM_color=300
muiriddinLone Peak 9 waterproof is what I am currently using. I am starting to tear apart the outsole after a year which is actually good for me (drag toes more than I should).
pdxritchmaSimilar to you, I (6' 190) actually had been hiking in Adidas Terrex for the last few years, and they work ok, but my feet definitely are feeling the pqin on long hikes. I recently bought a pair of the Altra Lone Peak Waterproof (just like the ones above, but waterproof...) and am absolutely loving them. The wide toe box is really nice... Super comfy so far. https://www.altrarunning.com/en-us/hike/mens-lone-peak-9-waterproof-low/AL0A85PM.html?dwvar_AL0A85PM_color=220 (Edit to URL)
rhefterAltra Lone Peak 9 Waterproof. I needed the wide toe box.
kbchuckerI switched to Trail Runners. I have Altras, low cuts for good weather and non-cold/muddy conditions. Mid cut with Goretex and leather for the cold and muddy conditions. I still wear my Lowas from time to time, but not for long hikes.
Nothing, people like what they like. I have a pair of LP5s, they’re great, but I don’t have a problem with the 9s.
Topo Athletic or Altra. Altra Lone Peak and Olympus are my go to trail shoes. Lone Peak has a Goretex version but I never bother with it. The upper drains fast and dries quickly. Get the Lone Peak 9+ for the vibram sole. Olympus has vibram also. Traction is great with both. I don’t have experience with Topo yet, but my wife and everyone else I know who has them loves them.
I’m tempted to try a pair, but have had issues finding a good size fit. LPs and Olys do well, but you are right, they tend to mileage out 500ish at most. Plus I am so used to the zero drop after several years of wearing them. How much of an issue would that be for me? Any at all?
I wear Lone Peaks for multiple surfaces all the time. You aren’t going to kill them on a two week trip.
Altra Lone Peak and Olympus have been my go to trail runners. I have very wide feet, so most of the brands you mentioned are not an option for me since they only offer a standard D width. Topo Athletic would be another brand I would consider but Altra has been working well for me long enough I am reluctant to switch.
mwf86Trail runners for grip. I play Altra Lone Peak Waterproof Lows in the wet months. They are treaded with no drop for a balanced feel.
NavyBlueZebraI have similar experience. My Winter Gore-Tex Lone Peaks have lasted for at least four winters, as the soles remain intact under my spikes, and the top is worn down, not fully water-resistant anymore, but no holes. And my current summer Lone Peaks are 600+ miles and the top is intact, and the lugs are slightly worn out. But this is a Vibram sole which cost extra $15 at REI. There isn't much foam in Loan Peaks, and I could care less if it's compressed.
2x Lone Peaks, 1x Superiors. 2000+ miles
Generally I'm getting at least 700-800 miles. Last year I did 2000+ miles, and two pairs of Lone Peaks were completely done for, and one pair of Superiors is still OK. Strengthening arches takes a lot of time, but eventually it worked for me - I no longer need cushioning, all I want is that small rocks and such do not bite my feet. I'm much heavier than you. YMMV of course, and what worked for me might not work for you.
same here, and that's a massive strain on my ankles. to go easy on the ankles, I'm always running in zero drop low stack shoes: Lone Peaks and Superiors. also I'm strengthening my ankles almost daily: 15-20 minutes of single legged balance excercises and calf raises. it's incredibly boring, I'm doing that while watching some movie. it works, I'm running completely pain-free
Personally on more technical trails I prefer lower stack, not more cushioning - it's way easier on my ankles, especially on steep downhills. And after some strengthening, and after working on my running form, I don't really need much cushioning any more. So while generally I run in Lone Peaks, I go for Superiors for my most rugged runs.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Deep mud and soft ground
Top pick
Salomon - Speedcross Series
Best for Quick draining and drying for wet trails
Top pick
Altra - Lone Peak Series
Best for Road-to-trail transitions
Top pick
Nike - Pegasus Trail Series
Best for Steep technical descents
Top pick
Altra - Lone Peak Series
Best for Technical rocky terrain
Top pick
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series
Best for Ultra-marathon racing
Top pick
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series
