Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
AdventurousWalrus285Altra will "train your feet". Just ease into them if you can. They'll make barely any difference if you are a forefoot striker. If you strike with the heel, check out cascadia 19s in the 2E and then if you can afford it rotate with the Altra Lone Peaks or Olympus 275 (make sure if the "Original" shape).
Any-Fish-3143Sadly the Timp is too narrow for me. The Topo Pursuit 2 is on the list and I will try it as soon as I get my hands on a pair. I tried several Altras (Timp 6, Olympus 6, Mont Blanc, Olympus 275), but none was a match.
BegattenI have the Olympus 275, if you're used to Zero drop (defo takes a long break in period), but I love them, however, it worth noting that they definitely feel 'dead' pretty quick, I've put about 250km on my Altra Lone Peak, tread in tack, but feel very dead. I've also got the Hiero v9, they're super nice, with 5mm drop, very very soft, so nice for those longer distances
BigShaker1177Altra Olympus 275!!!! I just did a 20 mile Mammoth March hike in one day and feet NEVER hurt!! Best ever!!
fangorn_foresterOlympus 275 is really good.
I'm an altra fan and imo the lone peak and olympus are their most durable shoes. Great for wide feet. However, I don't find them to be the best for scrambling despite having done some burly objectives in lone peaks. I've heard scarpa can be a good fit for slightly wide feet and are very durable as well. I'm eyeing scarpas ribelle and spin planet for the same reason as you - want a mountain runner that handles exceptionally well as a scramble too. Their ski boots are amazing fwiw.
Healthy_Software4238exp wide 3 has a 4mm drop, so closer to other standard drop brands, not really low drop. i wear exp wild 2’s and altra olympus 6 & 275 which are true zero drop. i’d give yourself a couple of hours per day & building up - if i wear the ew2’s for 5 days straight my first day in oly’s gives me some pain in the top of my foot and top of fib, but just for a day. some people new to the altra toebox width can benefit from toesox to pack it out - you may be experiencing some growing pains, give them a solid go before you chuck em out
InternalNarwhal1617For those who’ve tried them — what do you think? Too much shoe, or just right for long days out? Would you use them as your daily? I finally got some miles in on the new Olympus 275 and wanted to share my experience. I’ve been running a lot of Utah singletrack and climbing with them, and the *max cushion* plus grip really stood out. I put together a review video where I dive into the pros, cons, and who I think this shoe is best for. If you’re curious, here’s the link: [https://youtu.be/PYUU9lw\_TuY](https://youtu.be/PYUU9lw_TuY)
Valid point— I was curious about the same thing going in, but I will say the Olympus 275 feels more durable than some other max cushion shoes I’ve tested. I’ll have to put more miles on them to really see how the midsole holds up though. Have you found a trail shoe with better long-term cushion that you’d recommend?
kbchuckerAltra Olympus 6, Olympus Mid, or Olympus 275. All 3 will offer more cushion than the Lone Peaks. They should be plenty wide for you.
Check out the Altra Olympus 6 or 275. Asics Trabuco Topo Athletic Terraventure If you can’t find in a local store, order from their websites. They all have easy returns if you have size issues. For Altra, order 1/2 size up from your regular size.
You might want to order direct from Altra then. They recommend 1/2 size up from your normal shoe size. That has worked for me.
Probably because not everyone is looking for cushioned shoes in their trail shoes. I have been a fan of the Olympus models for several years, but particularly after I broke my leg a few years ago. They were the only shoes I could wear during my recovery when I was walking on hard surfaces for extended periods of time. I have had LPs, wearing a pair now. I really like them, too, but I prefer more cushion any time I am carrying weight or going on a long distance.
Topo Athletic or Altra. Altra Lone Peak and Olympus are my go to trail shoes. Lone Peak has a Goretex version but I never bother with it. The upper drains fast and dries quickly. Get the Lone Peak 9+ for the vibram sole. Olympus has vibram also. Traction is great with both. I don’t have experience with Topo yet, but my wife and everyone else I know who has them loves them.
I’m tempted to try a pair, but have had issues finding a good size fit. LPs and Olys do well, but you are right, they tend to mileage out 500ish at most. Plus I am so used to the zero drop after several years of wearing them. How much of an issue would that be for me? Any at all?
Altra Lone Peak and Olympus have been my go to trail runners. I have very wide feet, so most of the brands you mentioned are not an option for me since they only offer a standard D width. Topo Athletic would be another brand I would consider but Altra has been working well for me long enough I am reluctant to switch.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Deep mud and soft ground
Top pick
Salomon - Speedcross Series
Best for Quick draining and drying for wet trails
Top pick
Altra - Lone Peak Series
Best for Road-to-trail transitions
Top pick
Nike - Pegasus Trail Series
Best for Steep technical descents
Top pick
Altra - Lone Peak Series
Best for Technical rocky terrain
Top pick
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series
Best for Ultra-marathon racing
Top pick
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series
