Altra

Timp 5

Altra Timp 5

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#28 in

Trail Running Shoes

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score65% positive
11
2
4

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Oct 7, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconAniviaPls
7 months ago

Nah the timps are much better. Most of the lone peak data is from years past when there was no competition in the space. They are terrible to run in compared to the competition 

Reddit IconAny-Tailor-56
8 months ago

I love Altra! I wear the Timp 5.

Reddit IconCaminoT
4 months ago

Love love my Altra Timp 4 - bought 2 pair before they completely ran out online. Timp 5 and 6 sadly VERY disappointing. Why change a good thing? Anyone have a very gently used womens 7.5 or 8 the want to get rid of?

Reddit IconCaramelDays
7 months ago

I run on Timp 5s and they've been okayish, cushioning is not a problem at all (I come from road Gel Kayanos). The reviews I've seen for the 6 called them a better shoe than the 5s so it's worth a try!

6 months ago

I think you should use road to trail shoes instead. For example, running on my Altra Timps on road for a looong time is not comfortable.

Reddit Iconeasywizsop
6 months ago

I have been running in Altra Timp 5's for a while and picked up a pair of Lone Peak 9+'s. I notice immediately on a short jog that I feel the impact a lot more on the ground. Is there anything that I should do to get used to them before going out on a real run with them? I'm a little worried it will hurt or could lead to injury. The immediate positive I notice is how much better they walk or hike. Foot is a lot more stable natural to navigate terrain. Thanks everyone for your input.

Reddit Iconed_trav
12 months ago

Even with a really deep discount, I would skip Altras. My Timp 5 started falling apart with around 70 miles on them. My local running store has pretty much quit carrying them due to all the durability issues. There are so many good running shoes right now, that I think you would be much happier going with a better shoe as you get into the sport.

Top Trail Running Shoes on Reddit

1
Mount to Coast H1

Mount to Coast

H1

85% positive of 177 users

Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

2
Altra Lone Peak Series

Altra

Lone Peak Series

70% positive of 484 users

Spacious toe box, but cushioning and durability are polarizing.

3
La Sportiva Prodigio Series

La Sportiva

Prodigio Series

74% positive of 219 users

Great technical grip, but unstable for some, with sizing issues.

4
Nike Pegasus Trail Series

Nike

Pegasus Trail Series

75% positive of 223 users

Versatile for non-technical trails, but poor on wet, technical.

5
Mount to Coast T1

Mount to Coast

T1

87% positive of 84 users

Lightweight, cushioned; but lacing and underfoot protection are issues.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs