I’ve heard no so good things about ON, so would skip those.
Personally, I have arc’teryx Norvan LD 4s (they come in both gore tex and non gore Tex versions), they also have a vibram sole. I think they’re the most “normal” looking trail runners I could find and they have everything I need.
Trolling can be funny it’s a skill that you don’t have.
I have this shoe alongside Sylans and Norvan 4s. I run mostly single track and hard pack and they KILL my legs…because they aren’t meant for that kind of running. My lack of understanding what this shoe was for has in turn showed me what *is* good about them.
They fit snug, have great ground feel, are breathable and dry fast. Scrambling in them and hopping off rocks etc in them is great. I can’t see how this shoe could be great for technical terrain and groundbreakingly comfortable.
Comfortable is high in importance for road running but running on technical terrain it seems as though you must sacrifice that in exchange for stability, as the degree of both is decided by the same thing (the midsole)
I have a pair of Arc’teryx Norvan LD4 (non goretex). I also bought the Salomon Genesis but haven’t tried them out yet.
The Norvans were pretty great. Unlike my regular runners, they provided all day comfort without feeling sweaty at all. I was wearing merino wool individual toe socks for day to day and compression socks for the plane though.
I went with trail runners for the same reason as you- in a single shoe, I think they just offer the best tradeoff of daily use, feet protection, breathability, style (if you can get as close to all black as possible), durability, etc.
I have both those and they work really well for me for running.
It sounds like this is a walk though for which I personally prefer something a little firmer.
The Arc’teryc Norvan LD4 have worked really well for me for walking (but I think maybe too firm for running)
Prodigio Pro would handle this fine, or if you want less cushion, more precision then the Kjerag 2.
Mainly it's about the rubber compound on smooth rock, and La Sportiva and Vibram are top choices.
If you just want to mainly hike, then Norvan LD4 is a great cross-over shoe.
It's 4 mm. But honestly the Z2 didn't feel low like the Kiger 9's did. It's softer and with more rocker.
I prefer lower drop = more forefoot cushion and a more stable heel. Peg Trail 5 did suffer from a tall unstable heel. That limited it to less technical use.
For hiking a would go for something more grounded like the Norvan LD4.
Zegama 2s are are quite tall and soft and you don't need all this cushion for hiking anyway.
Ye I bought them for running, but now use 'em for hiking. I put Inov-8 boomerang insoles in them to help with comfort. Another thing is rockered shoes are generally terrible for hiking. The Norvan is pretty flat.
Only comparing to the Z2 here, but the Prodigio Pro is more a race shoe - more rocker, better lockdown, lighter weight, but maybe not the best comfort due the bootie upper and doesn't accommodate swelling well. I'm glad to take them off my feet at the end of a race.
Zegama 2 is more a comfort cruiser. Deeper cushion and more comfortable upper. It's a shoe where you prioritize foot comfort over pure performance. That might sound dumb, but foot comfort is often a priority in long Ultras.
I have the Prodigio Pro, but prefer a stiffer, lower, firmer, and less rockered shoe for hiking like the Norvan LD4. Prodigio Pros also have a bootie upper so they are quite resictive if your feet swell - would prefer to have a tongue like in the Prodigio Max.
Depends on the terrain and distance, but a superfoam does nothing for you hiking and the rocker is a hinderance on downhills. Prodigio Pro sizing is difficult to get right and the bootie upper doesn't allow for swelling. Hiking vs. Trail racing racing overlap not that high.
Personally I like the Norvan LD4 it's <$100. Or you could go for a popular through-hiking shoe like Topo Mnt racer, which offers more toe splay. All depends on your foot shape - that's the 1st consideration. Or Prodigio Max I've seen reduced if you want a high stack.
Lower stack = less ankle rolling and more connection with the terrain. Maybe try sth like Norvan Ld4, Kjerag 2, Salomon Pulsar if your distances are not too long.
Prodigio Pro is a rare highish stack shoe that does well in tech terrain. It crushes all other shoes in this class. Speedgoats go to sleep at night wishing they could be this shoe.
Top Trail Running Shoes on Reddit
1
Mount to Coast
H1
85% positive of 177 users
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.
dodoairways
