Speedgoat 6 GTX

I have Hoka Speedgoat 6 GTX for my 10 to 20 km runs and very happy with them.

I really like my speedgoat 6 offroad in the mud and walking in the mountains, but they lack a bit of damping for running <6min/km. So my next pair will be challenger 8's.

I've been out running through 5-10 cm of snow in my hoka speedgoat 6 GTX. The 7 just came out and should have some more cushioning (which they do need). Grip is pretty good with the vibram sole and like you say, going slow and enjoy the views 👌

Gtx model is waterproof with goretex. Same shoe just waterproof, $50 more and only a few colors vs the non waterproof have like 8 to 10 colors.

Hoka's for last 3yrs. Ones I have now are Speedgoat6 GTX. The GTX have goretex and are waterproof to an extent. I had a pair of Nike golf shoes 3yrs ago and had to take them off. Played hole 9 shoeless and got my sneakers at the turn. Plantar fascitis. Now I just need my knee sleeves and I jog half the course with my pushcart.

I returned my speedgoat 6 gtx after only 10 days of trail running and hiking. They were trashed. Toe cap peeling, dented midsole. These are not good shoes at all.

Another vote for these. I’m loving the traction on the ice and snow and my feet are quite toasty warm!

I’m personally a fan of Hoka’s, and I think this one fits your request: https://www.hoka.com/en/us/womens-trail/speedgoat-6-gtx/1155151.html?dwvar_1155151_color=BCKT

Of the models you're considering, the only ones I haven't owned are the Asics (but my wife has had them). I currently use the Brooks A24GTX as my everyday runner and love them - I returned to them this year after getting them annually for years before switching out to Hoka for a few pairs. Nothing against the Hoka's, they're super comfy and liked them a lot. I do think the speedgoats are overkill for you, I was using them exclusively on trail runs, where they were great. I've never really had the problem with water getting in and not getting out of any of my GTX trainers but it's a complaint I hear a lot, so it might just be that I don't notice or care. My wife has always loved the Asics too, she's been very consistently wearing last years version of them for her everyday runners for years now. EDIT: forgot to say i'm an overpronater too and run between 40-50k a week.

Just bought Hoka Speedgoat gtx 6 They are great! Get a half (or full) size bigger than you usually do tho to allow space for your big toe during downhills

I have both the non-goretex traditional speedgoats and the ankle height goretex version. I'd get the non-goretex version, the goretex are not breathable.

On the other hand, I had a brutal experience with the sg6 - blisters and a lack of cushion.  Went to the 001, and I found them to be a far more comfortable shoe. I would disagree with you on the max of 25km - having used them for a few races now I would say they would be good up to 100km.  I found them to be far more comfortable, but as always, ymmv