I really like my speedgoat 6 offroad in the mud and walking in the mountains, but they lack a bit of damping for running <6min/km. So my next pair will be challenger 8's.
I've been out running through 5-10 cm of snow in my hoka speedgoat 6 GTX. The 7 just came out and should have some more cushioning (which they do need). Grip is pretty good with the vibram sole and like you say, going slow and enjoy the views 👌
I have both and the speedgoats are pretty stiff. Theyre great for the deep mud but pretty harsh on the streets. Challenger is the best allrounder, really soft.
I have worn both over the last couple years and can confirm that Hoka is more comfortable and are as, if not more, durable. I use Hoka Mach 6s for pavement and the Hoke Speedgoat 6 gtx for Spartan races and trail running. My Spartan Race shoes fell apart after two sprints, a Beast and a Super. I’ve put my Speedgoats through the same and haven’t even had a loose thread or blown tread yet. They’re great.
I’m personally a fan of Hoka’s, and I think this one fits your request: https://www.hoka.com/en/us/womens-trail/speedgoat-6-gtx/1155151.html?dwvar_1155151_color=BCKT
Of the models you're considering, the only ones I haven't owned are the Asics (but my wife has had them).
I currently use the Brooks A24GTX as my everyday runner and love them - I returned to them this year after getting them annually for years before switching out to Hoka for a few pairs.
Nothing against the Hoka's, they're super comfy and liked them a lot. I do think the speedgoats are overkill for you, I was using them exclusively on trail runs, where they were great.
I've never really had the problem with water getting in and not getting out of any of my GTX trainers but it's a complaint I hear a lot, so it might just be that I don't notice or care.
My wife has always loved the Asics too, she's been very consistently wearing last years version of them for her everyday runners for years now.
EDIT: forgot to say i'm an overpronater too and run between 40-50k a week.
Top Trail Running Shoes on Reddit
1
Mount to Coast
H1
85% positive of 177 users
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.
27MonketBalls
