
Mount to Coast
H1
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Did my local this morning which was half tarmac, half The Somme. Did it in a pair of Saucony Xodus Ultra 3 which I got cheap in the John Lewis sale. They were decent, especially for a plodder like me. Did I get a PB? Did I heck as like. Did they keep me upright and not running like a Loony Tunes character? They did.
My wife has bunions and has found the Saucony Xodus Ultra 3 to be a fantastic choice. I also have wide feet, and am in love with my Xodus Ultra shoes.
I've been running in the Xodus Ultra 3 and I like them a lot. I'm 185 lbs and running on technical terrain. Went for a 22 mile run the other day in the rain. The trails could not have been any wetter, and I never slipped all day. I'm about to order the Xodus Ultra 4 so I have a chance to break them in before my next race.
I loved my speedgoat 5's so I tried their road shoes too. I think the Arahi 7's. Way too narrow of a toe box and gave me issues. That being said, I tried Saucony Xodus Ultra 3's and they wore down so quickly inside so I will probably never buy those again. Currently trying Topo Mountain Mountain Racer 4's
Some great tread still on these! I've purchased several pairs of the XU1s over the years. Still tough to beat. Wasn't a big fan of the XU2s or the XU3s, but the XU4s have been stellar. You might wanna check out the Nnormal Tomir 2.0. Those have been fun to run in lately for me.
Had the Speedgoat 6 but the soles of my feet were hurting a lot. Switched to the Saucony Ultra 3 and can only say they are absolutely lovely! Great grip running on gravel tracks and climbing mountain ridges. Are soft and yet sturdy. The only thing I would check is the stability of your ankles. They have a higher sole and it is a bit soft so you need to really focus on your running and where/how you place your feet. And I guess you will have this with all softer trail shoes. I also use them for hiking and so far they have been absolutely great also on steep hills, nasty descents and watery and muddy area.

Mount to Coast
H1
Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

Altra
Lone Peak Series
Spacious toe box, but cushioning and durability are polarizing.

La Sportiva
Prodigio Series
Great technical grip, but unstable for some, with sizing issues.

Nike
Pegasus Trail Series
Versatile for non-technical trails, but poor on wet, technical.

Mount to Coast
T1
Lightweight, cushioned; but lacing and underfoot protection are issues.

Ranked #1
Salomon - Speedcross Series

Ranked #1
Hoka - Speedgoat Series

Ranked #1
Mount to Coast - H1

Ranked #1
Salomon - Genesis Series

Ranked #1
La Sportiva - Prodigio Series

Ranked #1
Mount to Coast - H1