WHITIN

W51 Barefoot Trail-Running Shoes

WHITIN W51 Barefoot Trail-Running Shoes

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#222 in

Trail Running Shoes

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score67% positive
4
1
1
Last updated: May 12, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconMrKnee33
11 months ago

I have very wide feet and am using WHITIN’s W51 for trails and soccer and have had no issues regarding the toe box. One thing I would say is when I first got them I was getting cuts on the back of my ankle but now it’s not an issue.

Reddit IconBig_Disc_NRG
9 months ago

The Whitin trail running shoes on amazon are pretty good. $40ish per pair.

Reddit Iconchaparooski
9 months ago

I have a pair of these too. They are barefoot though and so for rockier courses you feel every little pebble or rock you step on. They still held up just fine, but went back to a more sturdy trail running shoe. For park courses, these are 100% my go-to shoe and you can't beat the price. Plus the wide toe box makes them very very comfy.

Reddit Iconclimbingbubba
9 months ago

I loved them so much I have multiple pair.. They are my work shoes too. So comfy. But when it's really rocky I go to my altras.

Reddit Icondidy115
4 months ago

I wear them! I’m not sure about the stack height meeting your requirements, but I like these and Whitin’s.

Reddit IconIceManBrrrrrrr
9 months ago

I was just coming down to the comments to call this out! Super comfy, but watch out for a sharp ass root or rock.

Reddit Iconnot_all-there
10 months ago

I used to run very regularly, several half marathons. A series of events and life obstacles led to me taking 7+ years off I am now over 2 months back into regular running. As a 50+ larger male, I am taking increasing super slow. I have some experience running barefoot, having completed one of my HM truly barefoot. But now I feel that variety is important to optimize my health and fitness My current shoe rotation is: 1. Whitin Trail runners - used on the road for "speed efforts" 2. Mizuno wave Neo Wind - used for my longer days up to 5k now, but a plan to grow to 10k I will use either for my easy shorter runs, for variety and I try to never wear the same shoe on consecutive days. For example I ran 5k Saturday in the Mizuno and a 1 mile easy recovery on Sunday in the Whitin.

Reddit Iconpassionfruit52a
4 months ago

How does the grip of the Pulltop's compare to the Whitin's? I have some Whitin's, but sometimes feel they lack decent traction on wet trails.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: