Xero Shoes

Mesa Trail II

Xero Shoes Mesa Trail II

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#37 in

Trail Running Shoes

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score83% positive
10
1
1

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Aug 25, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconrobot_ankles
6 months ago

Seconding Xero. After New Balance abandoned their trail running customers, I ordered Xero walking shoes just to checkout the material and build quality of what was (to me) an unknown brand. They've been great, durable, and still look pretty new despite a lot of use. When it was time for new trail runners, got those from Xero and they've been great. 14w flat and I love the Mesa Trail II Barefoot

Reddit IconSloppyCrabCakes
10 months ago

I’ve worn Xero shoes for the past five years, and I love them. I wear the scrambler lows right now and they’re great. Mesa Trail II are excellent as well (and they make great yard work shoes after you wear em down disc Golfing). I got two-three seasons out of them each

Reddit IconDirtWhomper
12 months ago

Try xero trail mesa. Nice wide foot shaped box. One thing to note is that wide shoes still tend to be traditional shoe shaped and not foot shaped.

Reddit Icongobluetwo
4 months ago

Altra Lone Peaks are significantly thicker than the Vivobarefoot shoes. I have an older pair and tried them for running, but didn't like it at all due to the high stack. I ended up using them as my winter and wet weather shoe. I would try some shoes by Xero. I trained for and ran a trail ultramarathon last year in the Xero HFS II. It's a good all-around shoe which is decent in easy to moderate trails. I wouldn't wear them for anything too technical or extreme (very sandy, muddy, loose gravel on steeps, etc.). It has about an 11mm stack height, including insole. You could also look at some of the low/mid top hiking options like the Scrambler or Mesa Trail. Otherwise, there

Reddit IconInverseInvert
6 months ago

Are you me? The only shoe that came close for me was the xero mesa, main downside is it’s a barefoot shoe so it’s super uncomfortable and my podiatrist has told me not to use them again. I had to settle with the brooks ghost 2 and accept there weren’t any wide trail shoes. Only large toebox. No one makes wide midfoot trail shoes. At all.

Reddit IconLongjumping_Pool_263
9 months ago

I love the Mesa trail but on longer more technical runs I go with the Altra king mt pretty low stack but has a rock plate. It’s a pretty great shoe

Top Trail Running Shoes on Reddit

1
Mount to Coast H1

Mount to Coast

H1

85% positive of 177 users

Versatile road-to-trail, but struggles on wet, technical downhills.

2
Altra Lone Peak Series

Altra

Lone Peak Series

70% positive of 484 users

Spacious toe box, but cushioning and durability are polarizing.

3
La Sportiva Prodigio Series

La Sportiva

Prodigio Series

74% positive of 219 users

Great technical grip, but unstable for some, with sizing issues.

4
Nike Pegasus Trail Series

Nike

Pegasus Trail Series

75% positive of 223 users

Versatile for non-technical trails, but poor on wet, technical.

5
Mount to Coast T1

Mount to Coast

T1

87% positive of 84 users

Lightweight, cushioned; but lacing and underfoot protection are issues.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs