
Cosco Kids
Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Super light, cheap, great for air travel, but outgrown fast.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Doona hater here. We got the Graco Snugfit 35 (whichever one came with the load leg base) and loved it!
Graco Snugfit 35 with the anti rebound bar, and the mockingbird single to double stroller!
We had the Graco in my 2016 for both kids and it did great. I had the police department locally help me install my first one to make sure I was doing it right.
Yes, I love having carseat compatibility with my stroller! We have the Graco snug ride snug fit DLX with the Graco Fastaction Jogger, we've used this with both kids and I love the ease it folds up, and the "real" tires which helps on all terrain. We also have the Cyber Gazelle with Graco adapter, because we have 2 under 2 and sometimes need the double stroller option. This stroller is so smooth and turns really easily even with one hand but is not so great in loose rocks or dirt. It really isn't a big deal to pop the carseat in to the stroller at home or get baby ready in the carseat and then take him out to the garage to pop it in when we go for walks. I like it because he then faces me, plus most strollers are not recommended until at least 6 months of age on their own so you either need to use a carseat or one with a bassinet attachment.
We did the graco snugride snugfit with my first and it was nice! I just hated lugging it around haha- not the seat’s fault, I’m just short and my baby got too heavy for me to carry it comfortably pretty quickly. She also had reflux so we switched to a chicco fit 360 at 6-7ish months. I’m due with our second in a month and we just went straight for the convertible this time. We still have the infant seat/stroller if we need it, but I figure with two we’d be using a double stroller most of the time anyways.
We used a bucket car seat up to a year for our almost 9lb at birth baby. He grew fast, and he still safely used it for a year. It was sooooo helpful for when he fell asleep in the car and we wanted to stretch the nap a little longer. I know people say don’t let baby sleep in the car seat - but sometimes continuing the nap was really worth it for us. We always kept our eyes on him if he was still asleep and stayed nearby. Also if baby doesn’t transfer well out of the car seat, keeping them in the infant seat makes it a little easier.
We use all graco :) we have the snugfit dlx for baby and the extend2fit for toddler!

Cosco Kids
Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Super light, cheap, great for air travel, but outgrown fast.

Cosco Kids
Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat
Portable, affordable, quickly outgrown, airplane buckle discomfort.

Joie
Mint Latch
Easy baseless LATCH install, lightweight, but quickly outgrown.

Nuna
PIPA Series
High-end travel, easy baseless install, but very pricey.

WAYB
Pico™ Portable Car Seat
Ultra-light, compact travel, quick install, but expensive and outgrown fast.

Ranked #1
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat

Ranked #1
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat

Ranked #1
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat

Ranked #1
Doona - Doona Series

Ranked #1
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next Convertible Car Seat

Ranked #1
Nuna - PIPA Series