
Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
Another thing to think about is how big car seats are. We basically had to go with the nuna rava as while we are rear facing it was the only one that would fit and still let us put the front seats back enough to be comfortable or safe to drive. A lot of them are just too big for our small ish suv (Mazda cx5)
Love them. Have the Pipa and Rava.
The seats they require are convertible-Nuna RAVA. The need for advance order doesn’t make it ideal, but I have had a great experience with the Uber car seat option in DC every time I used it. We actually got the same driver several times so I think the drivers are limited/selected so it’s reassuring it’s not any random person throwing a broken car seat in their trunk.
This is what we have. Rava in my Highlander and an extend2fit in my husband’s truck
I have the Nuna rava, I bought it for my oldest and he used it after he outgrew his infant seat around 6/7 months until he was about 3.5 years old. He’s a 99%ile boy and by 3.5y, the 5 point harness was too snug in the crotch area, so we switched him to the Nuna Aace at that point. My baby is currently using the Rava and it seems comfortable for him at 9.5 months old.
I have the Nuna rava (primary family vehicle) and my husband has graco extend2fit in his truck. Both are fine seats! The biggest difference I see is in the installation. I can swap a Nuna from vehicles in 1-2 minutes, versus the install for others is more challenging (not technically, but more manual pulling to make sure it’s secure). I had no issues at all installing my uppababy mesa for my child in my vehicle at 8 months pregnant. That being said, my 99%ile height babies both grew out of the infant seat by 6-7 months… so I wouldn’t necessarily recommend investing in an expensive infant seat!
I am the odd duck here. I have a 3 year old who I have traveled with quite a bit since they were 6 months old and I have always purchased the additional seat to fly them in their car seat. I also travel with their daily Nuna Rava carseat. It is nice to have piece of mind, safety wise and be hands free and know that they are extremely comfortable on the flight. Internationally, I have used a Graco SlimFit which is lighter than the Nuna Rava. Navigating through the airport…my toddler walks on their own two feet through the terminal and I stopped traveling with a stroller around their 2nd birthday. I check all luggage and just pack a backpack with necessities (i.e., phone, wallet, charger, change of clothes for little one, snacks, and a toy and book for LO). The carseat, I strap to a carseat dolly and just roll it through. Unfortunately, of course airplane aisles suck so boarding the plane I have to take it off the dolly. Then I just have LO walk in front of me to keep eyes on them and direct them with my voice as I carry the carseat back and get it installed. Taking a carseat is so worth it and I would love to see more parents kids prioritizing do so. I also want to point out I have done this MANY times traveling with just my little without my husband. Our go-to destination is about a 5 hour flight and LO does great in their seat.
i think it's luck? we also have the nuna pipa. baby one loved it from day one and always fell asleep while driving but would wake up at every stop light for a while. baby two will cry for a minute once we get started and then conk out and will not wake when we stop lol i do think car seats might make a difference. when my daughter grew out of the bucket seat we had gotten a nuna rava for my vehicle and a cheap one for my husbands. she HATED being in my husbands vehicle and whined for car rides. bought a second nuna rava and the complaints stopped immediately - i would imagine bucket seats have similarly different comfort levels for different babies.
The convertible seats can fit a newborn, but the recline will be so large that the seat is no longer compact. Extend to fit is the most compact, but not at the most reclined position which is what you’d need. I’d actually look at a nuna rava, it only has one recline position which is more compact than the most reclined position you’d need on the extend to fit. Hopefully that makes sense!
Just got a britax poplar for baby #2, our daughter has a rava but it isn’t as great in Canada as it is in the US so I wouldn’t recommend. The britax is just as nice and also flame retardant free.
I believe the nuna rava and the Graco extend2fit are two of the most compact front to back. The thing is even if you were to FF at the minimum age which is usually 2 it would probably be a problem with how far back your husband needs the seat. When forward facing kids can’t put their feet on the seat in front of them or it can cause serious pelvis injuries in a crash. My guess is that if he is sitting all the way back you would have a hard time preventing a two year old from putting their feet on the seat. It may be time for a bigger car if the compact front to back seats don’t work
Not necessarily true. Extended rear facing seats like the nuna rava and the Graco extend 2 fit rear face to 50 pounds and there is a new seat the axkid which rear faces to 65 pounds and is specifically designed with the intent that kids can rear faces to age 7
[this](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36918272/) study looked at 0-4 year olds and found a decreased injury rate for rear facing. [here](https://csftl.org/why-rear-facing-the-science-junkies-guide/) is an article from a CPST org that discusses some of the science behind rear facing recommendations specifically degree of spinal ossification. Sweden in particular is known for its emphasis on rear facing and has an especially rigorous testing process called the Swedish plus test. They currently only test rear facing car seats for that test but used to test forward facing as well and no forward facing car seats ever passed the test. The test is designed to put more emphasis on forces on a child’s neck during a crash. Overall though it’s an underresearched area. A lot of the research stops at age 2 so it’s hard to say exactly how much better extended rear facing is. Two is considered to be the safety minimum to forward face so if you made it to two that’s still a safe choice. And the most important thing with any car seat is a safe install if you need to FF your two year old bc it’s only way for all the kids to sit safely than that’s the best practice choice in your particular situation
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
Best for Budget-friendly occasional travel

Top pick
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Best for Economy airplane seats

Top pick
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Best for Frequent uber and taxi rides

Top pick
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Best for International travel (europe)

Top pick
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Best for Long-haul flight comfort

Top pick
Cosco Kids - Scenera Next DLX Convertible Car Seat
Best for Non-toxic materials

Top pick
Nuna - PIPA Series





