Miele

Guard S1

Miele Guard S1

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#156 in

Vacuum Cleaners

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score79% positive
11
1
2

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Jul 7, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit IconAmbitious_Use_9578
5 months ago

Okay, I'm a Miele owner, and after having uprights, cordless and canisters, have found I preferred the canister bagged vacuum. Easier to keep the inside chambers of the vacuum clean, plus with Hepa filtration, the air can be cleaner. You just have to buy a box of bags every year or so plus a HEPA air filter. That said, a good sealed Hepa option from Miele is the Guard S1 Electro. Powered head for carpets and a bare floor tool for bare floors. The bag and the Hepa filter clean the air the best, and it will be quieter than your old Shark. I think they have a 5 yr warranty too. The Hepa filter needs to be replaced once a year at $50, but clean air is worth it. But I can't say for sure about your cat problem, I'm not a pet person, but it's going to be better than that Shark.

4 months ago

To the OP, you are doing great in your selection process, don't stress about it. Also, you don't need to spend all 1200 for this. Among the Sebo and MIele there is no wrong answer, as long as you get a motor driven brush roller head instead of a turbo or air driven one. You didn't mention which type of Miele your wife grew up with, they used to make a corded upright but don't anymore, just the canisters. I'm going to assume that you guys would be fine with a canister vacuum. Both brands make great canister models, I would suggest for Sebo the E3 series, and from MIele Guard S1 Electro. You want the Parquet bare floor tool as well, which the Guard S1 has. If you opt for Sebo, get whichever E3 has both the electric powered brush bar and the bare floor tool. The S1 Electro is currently on Amazon for $759. And the MIele C3 Marin is $1117. If you opt for Sebo, the E3 premium is $1150. The dealer should give you a discount if you ask, offer to buy a box of bags as well. These are all excellent quality vacuums. Hepa filtration. Very quiet operation. Long warranties, though I think the Sebo has the longer warranty. If you opt for used, just make sure you get either a Sebo either E or D series for larger homes, with electric power head and bare floor tool. For Miele, the C2 or C3 series with the power head and bare floor tool. Get one in good condition and you should get 10 years out of a lightly used model. Good luck! Edit: spelling

3 months ago

When you say long term, how long are you hoping for? Because stick vacuums are not engineered to last like a good quality electric vacuum. For instance, Dyson stick vacuums have a 2 year warranty while Sebo vacuums have a 10 year warranty. Do you want to buy a new stick vacuum every 3+ years or would you rather buy once and cry once. I had a Miele that was about 14 years old when I gave it away, still working perfectly.

Reddit IconConBroMitch2247
3 months ago

I’m not 100% up to date on the new models in Canada but the only one suitable for carpet in your list is the guard s1 electro. You could also look at the guard L1. Of those two, I’d go with the L1. The powerhead is much better. I would also definitely look at a Sebo k3 or E3 as well.

3 months ago

IMO yes. The electric floor head is **much** better on the L1. The S1 has an ancient design. Keep in mind, Sebo has a 10yr warranty too. Still worth considering imo.

10 months ago

Check out r/vacuumcleaners As mentioned Miele and Sebo are top brands. You can safely ignore any shark or Dyson recs. They’re garbage. As is anything bagless.

10 months ago

Vacuum wars is a paid shark shill and not to be trusted. Hell Chris even appeared in a shark commercial. BIFL vacuums absolutely exist. They’re corded and bagged made by brands like Miele and Sebo.

5 months ago

*Cordless* Vacuums are disposable. **Corded and bagged** vacuums like a Miele or Sebo will last you 2 decades or longer. Ask r/vacuumcleaners

Reddit Icon_d0s_
10 months ago

Da bei der Mama der alte Miele Staubsauger eingegangen ist, und ich umgezogen bin durfte ich mich in letzter Zeit ein paar Mal mit Staubsaugern beschäftigen. Akku Sauger klingt erstmal cool: Klein, leicht, kein Kabel, yay? Mutter bekam also einen Kärcher VC6 (\~350€). * Im Vergleich zu einem normalen Staubsauger ist die Leistung von den Akku Dingern wirklich mies. Der Turboknopf leert den Sauger in \~15 Minuten. * Da auch der Motor und Akku im Handteil untergebracht sind lastet viel Gewicht in der Hand. * Kostet deutlich mehr verglichen mit herkömmlichen Staubsaugern * Lebensdauer vom Akku wird sicher noch ein Thema * Nach 2 Jahren haben wir einen Miele Guard S1 (\~160€) nachgekauft. Mama ist wieder zufrieden. Ich selbst habe einen PHILIPS FC9332/09 PowerPro um \~80€ von Amazon und einen Dreame D10 plus (\~200€) roboter weil ich zu faul zum saugen bin. Bin mit beiden sehr zufrieden.

Reddit Iconekswhyzee
7 months ago

Try the Miele. I've had one for years, the thing's a beast. No problem with dust, sand, metal screws that should've been put away, etc. [Costco has one at $200 off right now.](https://www.costco.ca/miele-guard-s1-compact-canister-vacuum.product.4000405419.html)

6 months ago

I love my Miele. Had it for over 10 years now. I have a dog and my own hair is quite long, my vacuum sucks it up from shag carpeting no problem. Here's some models specifically for pets: [https://hiarthur.com/?share=12d82de2-51ab-44e6-977d-68e7b05df285](https://hiarthur.com/?share=12d82de2-51ab-44e6-977d-68e7b05df285)

3 months ago

I love my Miele. Had it for over 10 years now. I have a dog and my own hair is quite long, my vacuum sucks it up from shag carpeting no problem. Here's some models specifically for pets: [https://hiarthur.com/?share=12d82de2-51ab-44e6-977d-68e7b05df285](https://hiarthur.com/?share=12d82de2-51ab-44e6-977d-68e7b05df285)

Reddit IconFar-Improvement1850
11 months ago

I can confirm that the new Guard S1 DOES have a premotor filter! The Guard S1 Electro also comes with a powered brush, which was a must-have for me.

11 months ago

I can confirm that the new Guard S1 DOES have a premotor filter! The Guard S1 Electro also comes with a powered brush, which was a must-have for me.

Reddit Iconglove2004
3 months ago

Just want to say thank you for posting this. I bought a s1 electro last week and this post let me know that I can get it price adjusted for this new sale! Got almost 300$ cad back!

3 months ago

Im enjoying it. My carpet pile is probably too big for it though. Bought the seb228 power head so will see how that goes

Top Vacuum Cleaners on Reddit

1
SEBO AIRBELT E3 Premium

SEBO

AIRBELT E3 Premium

88% positive of 202 users

Ultra-durable, 10-year warranty, but expensive with short cord.

2
Numatic International Henry Canister Series

Numatic International

Henry Canister Series

79% positive of 388 users

Budget king, super durable, but heavy and poor on carpets.

3
SEBO AIRBELT D4 Premium

SEBO

AIRBELT D4 Premium

90% positive of 154 users

Durable, powerful, long cord, but heavy and pricey.

4
SEBO FELIX Premium

SEBO

FELIX Premium

87% positive of 117 users

Durable, powerful, good for allergies, but heavy with awkward attachments.

5
Miele Classic C1 Cat & Dog PowerLine

Miele

Classic C1 Cat & Dog PowerLine

88% positive of 132 users

Durable, powerful, quiet, but very expensive, short cord.

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs