Simplicity Jill

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#97 in

Vacuum Cleaners

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score90% positive
9
1
0
Last updated: May 18, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconboiled_chud
about 1 month ago

When I first bought the house and was renovating it I used shop vacs. I actually had a shop vac on each floor because I got tired of lugging them up and down the stairs so often. So I had one in the basement, one on the first floor, and one on the second floor. Now I use a Simplicity Jill that I got off Amazon. I've had that for a few years now. Works decent enough to vacuum up cat fur, dog fur, and old house dust. I'd recommend getting a vacuum that uses bags. I used bags in the shop vacs too when I was renovating full bore. Old houses make a lot of dust (at least the ones I could afford do). Bagged vaccums will be better suited for that environment compared to bagless ones.

Reddit IconConBroMitch2247
8 months ago

Yes I’d definitely avoid cordless/bagless. They’re junk for the most part. What kind of budget are we talking? A Simplicity Jill is a great budget option if your rugs are very low pile. You can always add a wessel werk TK286 if you need more cleaning power for the rugs. Check out a Miele C1 pure suction or turbo team as well.

8 months ago

Yep - simplicity Jill, and there is extra budget left over for the wessel werk turbo attachment if you need better agitation on your rugs.

7 months ago

Yep you’re on the right track. If you can get the carpet out first, you could do a simplicity Jill (it’s better built than the mighty mite) neither of these will do carpet well. Or if not grab a Kenmore 200/400 series.

7 months ago

IMO yes return it. You have 100% hard floors? No rugs? In that same budget Grab a simplicity Jill. It will do blinds and baseboards better than an upright. Plus it has no brushroll for debris to get caught on. Which is ideal for 100% hard floors and fur.

9 months ago

Miele C1 pure suction. Short of that, simplicity Jill.

Reddit IconCurrent_Anybody8325
6 months ago

For your small space with no carpet, I actually would recommend the Simplicity Jill. It's essentially the same thing as a Bissell Zing, but with much higher quality accessories and HEPA filtration. We LOVE to recommend Miele here, but a Miele would honestly be overkill for your use case. I do, however, think a canister is the right form factor for your situation.

Reddit IconJ3ttf
12 months ago

Then the Jill is a great pick!

6 months ago

If you have hardfloors, you don't want a brushroll at all. Look into the Simplicity Jill, it will handle your home much better. Pair it with a TK286 turbo brush for your carpet, assuming it's not too thick.

Reddit IconLucky_Guess4079
10 months ago

1. Bagless is a mistake 2. Cheap bagless is foolish 3. You can get a great bagged vac with Simplicity starting at 169 for the Jill Or 269 EZM60 Bagless vacuums are not BFL.

Reddit IconOld_Man_Smell
6 months ago

A Miele C1 is excellent, but a Simplicity Jill and upgrading floor head to a Wessel Werk RD285 Designation is a crazy good value. It’s not going to be as quiet or maneuver quite as nice as the Miele, but yah if you want to save some cash it’s a great setup for your home.

Reddit IconRexSki970
3 months ago

We have a Simplicity Jill or Jane. It works GREAT at getting cat hair up and our own hair. And the filter and bag is great. Holds a lot of stuff. 10/10.

Reddit IconSlow-Shoe-5400
7 months ago

None. They’ll all do fine at first but you’ll have the same cat litter issue if you’re using a roller. Get a simplicity Jill. It’ll work better and last longer and it’s under 200.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: