Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Top Pros
Top Cons
Reddit Reviews
Amhaeng_EosaI use 2 Asus Ax59U and they work perfectly
BeerCDJust got an RT-AX58U refurb from Amazon for $75. It works great.
dondreddId go with asus just personal choice never any issues i have the ax58u,1 gig service,2,980sqft.
dwojc6I’d go with the AX58U between these options
elreomnyo for a $200 budget with Proxmox, NAS, and remote streaming needs, you're gonna want something that can actually handle the load. your current C54 is definitely choking with 14 devices and Tailscale encryption. under $200 options that make sense: · TP-Link Archer AX55 ($80-90) - AX3000, 2.5G port, handles VPN decently. plenty for 14 devices and Jellyfin transcoding won't phase it · ASUS RT-AX58U ($150ish) - better QoS, actually useful for prioritizing gaming traffic when someone's streaming from your NAS. AiMesh ready if you expand later · MikroTik hAP ax2 ($120) - if you're running Proxmox you probably don't mind tinkering. RouterOS is powerful, handles WireGuard/Tailscale like a champ. steeper learning curve but way more control · GL.iNet Flint 2 ($180) - OpenWrt based, built for VPNs, has 2.5G ports. Tailscale works great on it for your use case specifically: since you're hosting Jellyfin remotely, look for something with hardware NAT and good VPN throughput. the AX55 or Flint 2 are solid. stay away from super cheap WiFi 7 routers at this budget - the dual-band ones perform similar to WiFi 6 anyway your 2-room apartment doesn't need massive coverage so focus on CPU power for handling Tailscale encryption + multiple streams
ErkkiKekkoAwesome guide! I'm using Q3 with asus rt-ax59u (PC: 5700x3d, 4080S), and it runs GREAT. Stable connection with 600-750mbps bitrate on AL.
exile1972Bummer to hear. I haven't run into any of those issues with the RT-AX58U and RT-AC3100.
Simply can't beat Asus. Had them for years as well and they work flawlessly.
Motorola MB8611 modem and Asus RT-AX58U router. Both of these are fully compatible with Comcast.
FreeConnectGuyFor a 1,200 sqft apartment with 2-3 people and multiple devices, you don't need anything crazy. A solid dual-band WiFi 6 router in the $80-120 range will handle this easily. The TP-Link Archer AX55 (\~$80) or the ASUS RT-AX58U (\~$100-120 on sale) are both strong picks in your budget. WiFi 6 matters here mostly because you have a lot of devices it handles congestion better than older standards, which makes a real difference when everyone's on at the same time. since you're plugging your gaming PC into ethernet anyway, the router's wifi performance is mainly for everyone else's phones/laptops, so you don't need to overspend chasing the fastest wifi specs. Just make sure whatever you get has a decent number of ethernet ports if you want to wire anything else in.
Rankings by Use Case
Top recommendations from others in the same boat
