NETGEAR

Nighthawk Pro Gaming XR500 Wi-Fi Router

NETGEAR Nighthawk Pro Gaming XR500 Wi-Fi Router

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#404 in

WiFi Routers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score43% positive
3
2
2

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Jun 9, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Icondabig49
4 months ago

I currently have a 6-7 year old Netgear Nighthawk XR500 looking to replace. I'm looking to switch over to ASUS Looking to get a Dual Band WiFi 7 router the ones I'm looking at that are in my budget are.. RT-BE82U and the RT-BE86U Don't do any gaming.....primarily steam a lot and use laptops for browsing and have RING devices. Thanks

Reddit IconFriskyWisky2
3 months ago

I live in the UK, and I am an EE customer on their top package, (guaranteed 1.8gbps) at all times, but often goes over 2gbps. I ditched the EE provided router as it wasnt that great for IoT and their provided Wifi Extenders were pretty rubbish and limited to WiFi 5 only. I instead replaced it with TP-Link Deco BE9300, which has been brilliant. I get great WiFi in all areas of my home, and I get solid 2gbps when hard wired, the addition of WiFi 6 allows me to use that on supported devices and its noticeable. In terms of the infrastructure so far, its pretty good, and I'm happy with my setup. However, the Deco's above have limited features in regards to traffic management and QoS. There is a QoS option but its basically you add a device, and thats about it, and from my testing it really doesnt do anything, making me think its not actually prgrammed very well and instead is just a tick box in the app to say it "has QoS" when in reality it is literally just a tick box. I need QoS mostly for gaming, as I live in a heavy useage internet household, and I most game these days through streaming services (GeForce NOW being the primary). I plan to buy a router, to do the routing for the house, and put the Deco's into AP mode hard wired to a new router. When i search "best gaming routers" there are a few key ones to choose from but most are £700+ it seems like a lot of money, and when I look at it, its because they all come with super robust features and a strong WiFi offering (which I wont be using, as my chosen router will end up with its WiFI off, opting to use the Deco as my WiFi solution.) I literally want recommendations on cost effective routers, that wil manage all the routing DHCP etc, but comes with solid QoS for gaming and supporting the gaming side. Also ideally a minimum of 2.5gbps ports. There are some solid routers around £100 - £150 like the Netgear XR500 (i used one of these years ago) but its limited to 1gbps on the ethernet. Does anyone know of any solid options that are cost effective?

Reddit Iconboshbosh92
7 months ago

yeah I stopped buying gaming routers 4 years ago. I was on my 3rd nighthawk - they would no joke die consistently 2-3 months after their warranty expired. 3 of them in a row, like clockwork. I went with a mesh system and I am very pleased with it. it allows me to have solid fast wifi in my detached garage, which wasn't possible with the gaming router. and I have overall way better signal on the other stories of my house. I get close to 1 gig on wifi now. the mesh system, which includes 4 routers, was also cheaper than my nighthawk. never going back tbh

Reddit IconMatrix5353
12 months ago

Yeah, I gave up on consumer grade crap too, after I had a Netgear Nighthawk system that would randomly start spazzing out and start dropping packets on the wireless network and need a full power cycle every once in a while. Ended up going with Ubiquiti a few months ago and I've been pretty happy with it so far.

Reddit IconAcademic-Swimming919
9 months ago

I agree. I have tried numerous Netgear products, going back to a PCMCIA card, and all of them have had problems. The last Nighthawk I had constantly resulted in "Connected, No internet" for too many devices.

Reddit IconAccomplished-Ruin945
5 months ago

I moved from a Netgear Nighthawk router and extender to an Orbi network... Well worth it to me.

Reddit IconAppropriateDevice84
Reddit IconATypicalJake
8 months ago

You just need to create an account and load an app on your phone to set it up. I find the Unifi app to be substantially better and more intuitive than the Netgear Nighthawk app I had for my last router. Lots of youtube videos on how to set it up too. Super simple. Only warning I will give you is that the system will tend to grow over time. I started with a gateway, switch, and two access points a year ago. Now I have a NVR and 5 cameras too, as well as a couple outdoor AP’s.

Rankings by Use Case

Top recommendations from others in the same boat

Other Reddit Recommendations: