NETGEAR

Nighthawk X4 AC2350 Smart WiFi Router

NETGEAR Nighthawk X4 AC2350 Smart WiFi Router

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.

Overall

#306 in

WiFi Routers

according to Reddit Icon Reddit

Sentiment score50% positive
2
1
1

Top Pros

Top Cons

Last updated: Jun 30, 2026

Reddit Reviews

Reddit Iconozzuneoj
9 months ago

I have no experience with this router, so I cannot vouch for this specific model. That said, I feel like I should present what is probably an unpopular opinion on Reddit: Deals for consumer\gamer level networking gear like this tend to get downvote bombed because the popular opinion is that semi business level gear from Ubiquiti and others is so much better that no should be buying anything else. I went down that road for several years when helping friends and family with network upgrades (usually Edgerouter-X and a Unifi AP). What I found was that it was no more reliable than a decent home router\AP, and in a lot of cases it was actually MORE finicky, with well known issues and complications. The fixes for those, if they existed, were at times beyond my skill level as someone who isn't a networking professional and has no knowledge of the Linux command line (if it was MS-DOS I might do better... LOL). So, I had to rely 100% on solutions people came up with online, and the actual homeowner could basically do nothing on their own. Anyway, some of those users have since switched back to a decent consumer level gear from Asus or others and they never have any throughput or reliability issues when I ask them. Me personally? I bought a Netgear R7500v2 for $50 on post-black-friday clearance from Walmart in 2015 (it was $200 normally) and it has worked flawlessly for 10 years. The wireless throughput is plenty for my devices and it has been rock solid (up to date third party firmware is available for this model). The secret to having reliable internet for me has been to have my router + modem on a battery backup. So, it only goes down when I manually reset it or the ISP is having issues, and small dips in power do not cause the router to get stuck in a non-functional state. So yeah, if you are interested in learning about networking, the slightly more pro-oriented gear is probably good, but don't disregard consumer level gear. It can most definitely work fine, even for PC enthusiasts.

Reddit Iconrandomguy9731
10 months ago

Not an expert but sharing my very recent experience. I had an old nighthawk Netgear router from 2018 that started to act up, so I got a newer WiFi 7 router from Netgear (RS90) and it was even worse than the old one. After hours on the phone with tech support they couldn’t do much, so I returned it and went with a TP-Link WiFi 6 mesh (Deco X55 AX3000) and it has been working great.

Reddit Iconboshbosh92
8 months ago

yeah I stopped buying gaming routers 4 years ago. I was on my 3rd nighthawk - they would no joke die consistently 2-3 months after their warranty expired. 3 of them in a row, like clockwork. I went with a mesh system and I am very pleased with it. it allows me to have solid fast wifi in my detached garage, which wasn't possible with the gaming router. and I have overall way better signal on the other stories of my house. I get close to 1 gig on wifi now. the mesh system, which includes 4 routers, was also cheaper than my nighthawk. never going back tbh

Reddit IconDecafstab
26 days ago

You can totally get away with 1 router. How I have it set up, is I have a 5HGz router (nighthawk) controlling all my home WiFi needs. Off the back of that router, I have a Ethernet cable going to another router (my BE9300 TP link) and that’s in my room. My BE9300 broadcast its own WiFi 6GHz network, aka my dedicated VR network that nothing else is on it. A common misconception is that streaming VR to your headset uses your internet connection. This is completely false. It just used the WiFi band AS its connection to your headset uses set. This is how you can play WiFi with no internet on standalone games completed disconnected from the web. What can cause issues is when multiple devices are fighting for the connection and it can intermittently interrupt the VR connection from time to time making to jarring. When I used my 5GHz network on my nighthawk there was noticeable hitches and high latency issues at times. Ever since I swapped to my 6GHz BE9300 it’s been flawless. So your set up would be like this: Modem > Router (for home WiFi) > ethernet to VR router > VR router Ethernet to PC If you want to try without a dedicated VR router it’s this: Modem > Router > Ethernet to PC It’s pretty simple and isn’t complicated as people make it out to be. I’d recommend watching this if you’re interested in the VR router setup. But if it’s in the same room that you’ll be gaming on, you can probably get away with a router that just does triband (2.4,5,6GHz) networks https://youtu.be/9Ugy8ZC26tE?si=YojtyVEOvNc--3GB

Reddit IconAcademic-Swimming919
9 months ago

I agree. I have tried numerous Netgear products, going back to a PCMCIA card, and all of them have had problems. The last Nighthawk I had constantly resulted in "Connected, No internet" for too many devices.

Reddit IconAccomplished-Ruin945
6 months ago

I moved from a Netgear Nighthawk router and extender to an Orbi network... Well worth it to me.

Top WiFi Routers on Reddit

1
GL.iNet GL-MT6000 (Flint 2)

GL.iNet

GL-MT6000 (Flint 2)

91% positive of 199 users

OpenWrt enthusiast's choice; good value, but lacks 6GHz.

$135 Amazon
Prime Day Deal
2
Ubiquiti Dream Router 7

Ubiquiti

Dream Router 7

85% positive of 228 users

Advanced management, but limited Wi-Fi 7 range, SFP+ issues.

3
Ubiquiti Dream Machine Series

Ubiquiti

Dream Machine Series

89% positive of 97 users

Comprehensive control, stable for large homes, but slow support.

4
Ubiquiti UniFi Dream Router (UDR)

Ubiquiti

UniFi Dream Router (UDR)

94% positive of 78 users

Modular, user-friendly, but tricky advanced setup, poor penetration.

5
GL.iNet Beryl AX (GL-MT3000)

GL.iNet

Beryl AX (GL-MT3000)

90% positive of 73 users

Travel king, versatile, OpenWrt, but bulky power adapter.

$79 Amazon
Prime Day Deal

Rankings by Use Case

Other Reddit Recommendations:

FAQs