
Apple
AirPod Pro Series
Apple-integrated, great ANC, but fit issues & poor Windows support.

Running these analyses costs money. Buy through my links to help keep lights on! I may get a small commission.
Love mine! I also have a pair of shockz, but the sound quality even for open ears is just so much better! They’re more expensive but totally worth it in my opinion. I owned the soundsport for almost 10 years and they’re still working and so far the open ears works great.
I got bose sound sport for this reason keeps me aware out and about and also in the office I can turn in to people's convos still
I’m in the marking for a new pair of wireless earbuds that aren’t gonna crap out on me. For reference, I’ve had the apple AirPods Pro 2nd Gen and the Bose Soundsport. The AirPods are the most fragile earbuds I’ve ever used, I like to think I’m quite careful when it comes to earbuds but it didn’t take long for them to stop working after a couple falls to the floor or a splash of water or sweat got on them. They also had very harsh treble to my ears. The Bose’s battery just wasn’t up the standard and wore out very quickly, also wouldn’t charge fast or well. I’m looking for good sound quality, something that won’t hurt my ears after long periods, and won’t break or wear out quickly. I’m not exactly enthusiastic about dropping $400 on a pear of earbuds, but if I know they will last a long time then I’ll consider it.
Hi there - I was a Bose Soundsport + QuietComfort Fan for a while - both started crackling after a few years of use. Then this sub turned me onto the Sennheiser Momentum True Wireless 2 and purchased a pair in April 2023. Loved them but they died in less than a year... I complained and they sent me a brand new (or maybe refurbished idk) Momentum 3. Those died in about two years (one ear bud stopped charging) and purchased the Sennheiser CX True Wireless as a "lower cost" option in Jan 2024... it is now Apr 2026 and one Earbud is just refusing to connect, but is "on". Did a factory reset, etc. I am now scared to buy For my needs, I don't really care about the best quality sound (I mean, not potato quality) or noise cancelling. I ride the subway, plug these in at work, and workout with them. I just need something that won't die in 2 years and maybe holds a 6-8+ hour charge. I'm kind of sick of shelling out money every couple years and just having them poop out. To be fair, I am okay with spending more money but I want to be sure that these will at least give me 3 years of use and get me through a long haul plane ride. I *would* buy headphones but I dont like sweating/working out with literal earmuffs and for me, they are nice-to-haves not need-to-haves. EDIT: I purchased the EarFun AirPro 4 (not plus) to hold me over and I love them. (Even though my bf said he will buy me a pair of Sony). Perfect for my needs, not a super distracting ANC, good sound for gym/commuting def not as warm as Sennheiser but as a non-audiophile, this works, and only $60 bucks so if they die in 2 years, I wont be too eaten up about it. I'll likely upgrade to the 4+ once these die to see how I feel about it.
I tried to QC buds as a replacement for my Soundsport buds but they never really fit well, despite trying all the band and tip options, including special ordered extended sizes. The "wings" on the Soundsport buds worked really well and not having them on the QCs was a real setback. I then got the Ultra Open buds and love them. Super comfortable, never fall off, sound great. Only drawback is the outgoing call audio is BAD. Otherwise, I'm very happy and don't really miss the noise cancelling. I run a lot, too, and appreciate good sound while also having some awareness of what's going on around me. They're also so comfortable it's easy to forget they're on.
u/Fearless-Wonder-1617, Neither the Airpods nor the QCU Earbuds have those wings as the Sport Earbuds have. The QCU Earbuds have a very small rubber ring, but it just doesn't compare with the fitmen than the Bose Sport Earbuds have. We have in our household 3 sets of Bose Sport Earbuds and also we have 3 sets of the QCU Earbuds as well (though 1 set went defective right when the those were out of warranty, so working we have since 2 sets, which work still to this date). In my experience, the Sport Earbuds have the wings that you mentioned in your post and that allows them to stay better fit in the ear, especially if you have movement, far better than the QCU Earbuds will. With regard to flying, there was a similar post, just a couple of days prior: [https://reddit.com/r/bose/comments/1t99jq1/earbuds\_or\_headphones\_for\_flights/](https://reddit.com/r/bose/comments/1t99jq1/earbuds_or_headphones_for_flights/) Thus, with those answers on that post, the onlly variable left is running. In my experience, the QCU Earbuds, especially the left Earbud, falls out of my ear VERY easily and there are other posts, even on this subreddit of other redditors with the same problem as well. Though i've tried a number of options, ie trying to tuck the earbud as much as possible in the ear, still falls off relatively easy, especially if there is movement. For that reason, for running, you might have the same challenges with the QCU Earbuds too. So if you were to go for the QCU Earbuds, then you could get an anti-loss strap, similar to the example in the link below: [https://www.amazon.de/MOWYEOK-Anti-loss-Headphones-Compatible-QuietComfort-black/dp/B0CG1QZJ8G](https://www.amazon.de/MOWYEOK-Anti-loss-Headphones-Compatible-QuietComfort-black/dp/B0CG1QZJ8G) and there are other variant, even I've found wings for the QCU Earbuds, like in the example in the link below: [https://www.etsy.com/de-en/listing/4422107780/ultra-comfort-ear-wing-for-bose-qc-ultra](https://www.etsy.com/de-en/listing/4422107780/ultra-comfort-ear-wing-for-bose-qc-ultra) but, just like the Wings for the Airpods Pro, they won't fit while the Earbuds are in the charge case and you may need to remove them before placing them in the charge case. Because, I just want to avoid having to fiddle with removing each time those extra accessories, before I put the earbuds back in their charge case, I just simply have avoided getting those extra accessories and I just have to be very careful when I'm wearing the earbuds, as, at least for me, the left earbud, will far easily fall off my left ear, than the right earbud will. As for sound quality and since you already have the Bose Sport Earbuds, well, you will NOT be dissappointed. Infact, the QCU Earbuds, sound THAT much and better, as you'll have ANC available, that the Sport Earbuds lack + the QCU Earbuds when they were new, I was getting close to 9 hours of battery life... though now, afer 2+ years of use of the QCU Earbuds, they've settled to between 5-6 hours of use (with ANC turned off. If ANC is on, then the battery will range between 4ish hours). Our Bose Sport Earbuds, which are far older than the QCU Earbuds, of the 2 left working sets we have, 1 set will give normally 2 to max 3ish hours of battery life, which is very short while the second still working set, will give 4ish hours of battery life.. sadly the 3rd set died a horrible death... just in one of the use cycles, when the run our of battery power and I put them in their respective charge case, they never charged back and only glow/blink red and I still have those dead Sport Earbuds, just can't use them (they died 3+ years ago --as of the time of this post--), which is the unfortunate death cycle. I tried to see if I could plug them and re-install the firmware, unfortunately without success. So sadly, we've been left with those 2 remaining sets + now we have the 3 sets of QCU Earbuds, which are better in every category, outside of the grip in the ear : ( So from the Quality stand point, sound, battery life, with the QCU Earbuds, you WILL see a significant improvement in the battery life.
> Have you compared the less expensive QC earbuds to Ultra? u/Fearless-Wonder-1617, we own only the types mentioned previously (in addition to the SoundSport, but those were traded while in warranty and that's how we got the Bose Sport earbuds) : (. With that said, a coleague of mine, who has QC earbuds, as soon as he saw my QCUs, he immediately asked me the exact question, as he has the same problems with the left earbud falling easily of the ear. I did not test with my coleague's Earbuds, because I just don't feel comfortable putting someone else's Earbuds in my ear. > It seems that Bose and AirPods fitting in ear is extremely subjective. That has to do mainly, that heads are build not the same ; ). So where one individual may have no problems with fittment, another person will. Now, on the same individual's head, why one earbud 'falls' or slips out easier than the other, is due to the head not being identycally simetrical, ie, one half of the head, is a tiny different than the other side - that slight difference in the ear canal is enough for the earbuds, that don't have anywhere else to hold a grip, to just fall off the ear canal.
u/Equivalent_Song_8164, that is an interesting experience that you've had with the outgoing call sound experience. In my personal testing between as we also used to have the Soundsport earbuds as well (and infact, I still have 2 extra charge cases for the Soundsport, which back in the day, those Earbuds wer NOT paired to the case, so you could get as many extra charge cases, which worked perfectly not only for charging, but also for resetting the earbuds as well. The Bose Sport earbuds as well as the QCU Earbuds are paired to the case, so while exchange cases will work for charging, with those other cases, there will be an issue if there is a need to factory reset and/or pair with new devices, as those Earbuds, are paired to their cases from the factory -> thus without the original case, those Earbuds, well won't work with those replacement cases for pairing, factory reset, but as long as you don't have that need --knock on wood, that you will never need to reset them, or pair them with a new device--, then for charging, the replacement cases will work) - The Soundsport earbuds had the 'worst' outgoing call sound -> and by 'worst' meaning that the person on the other end, could hear me well, just the sound sounded 'muffled', that is in comparison to the next other 2 earbuds we've had in the household, namely. - The Bose Sport earbuds would be in the middle, that is in comparison to the - QCU, which by far, are the ones that have the best sound all around, including for outgoing calls as well.

Apple
AirPod Pro Series
Apple-integrated, great ANC, but fit issues & poor Windows support.

OnePlus
Buds 4
Budget ANC king, but no wireless charging & windy transparency fails.

Beats (Apple)
Fit Pro
Workout secure, Apple-friendly, but wing-tips tear and case feels cheap.

Anker Soundcore
Sport X20
Value workout buds, secure fit, but connectivity can be iffy.

EarFun
Air Pro 4
Budget champ with great sound/ANC, but transparency has static.

Ranked #1
Apple - AirPod Pro Series

Ranked #1
Technics - EAH-AZ100

Ranked #1
Beats (Apple) - Fit Pro

Ranked #1
ISOtunes - PRO Aware 2.0

Ranked #1
Apple - AirPod Pro Series

Ranked #1
Shokz - OpenFit Series