NEMO - Tensor All-Season Ultralight Insulated Sleeping Pad

I have the Tensor All Season, my brother has the Rapide and I’ve had the Dura 3R in the past so I have a decent idea of what they’re like. For one thing those specs are off, the Nemo packs the smallest and it’s definitely lighter than the Rapide at the same length and width. I use 25in wide pads though. As for comfort, these are all comfortable pads, it’s really going to come down to preference. The Exped and BA have more of a vertical baffle feel while the Nemo is more dimpled. If I had to rank them I’d go BA, Nemo, Exped. But it’s close, they are all good. For durability only the Nemo and Exped list the denier, w Nemo being 20 top, 40 bottom nylon. The Exped is 20d poly which is not only the thinnest but Poly isn’t as strong as Nylon. The BA doesn’t say the material but it seems durable. All of them should sleep true to their R value, so Nemo would be the warmest, and I’ve heard the Rapide has complaints of cold spots but my brother never experienced that, though he hasn’t tested it when it’s been cold enough. I really like that Exped uses synthetic fill rather than reflective film as it will be more comfortable in summer. So maybe go w the Exped if you’ll do a lot of summer camping and either the Nemo or BA depending upon what’s more important, comfort & durability -Rapide or weight & warmth - Nemo. Also look into warranty terms, being in Germany the Warranty won’t be the same buying from either US company.

Tensor is the best all around UL pad. The S2S isn’t meaningfully more comfortable, none of the ultralight options are. Try it next to a pad like the Megamat Ultra that has vertical sidewalls and you’ll see what I mean by meaningfully more comfortable, but it’s much more bulky and about a pound heavier. I use mine on all my rafting/kayaking trips. For backpacking it’s the Tensor every time.

The Featherstone Calcatta is also supposed to be a good budget pad. I have a Tensor All Season, the lifetime warranty justifies the extra cost imo.

No the sleeping bag won’t help much. To get a significant bump in comfort you’ll have to jump into some heavier pads that are still compressible enough to bring backpacking. Pads like the Thermarest Neoloft or Exped Megamat Ultra. I have a Tensor All Season and find it comfortable, however my Exped Synmat 3D (older version of the Megamat Ultra) is definitely more comfortable. My brother has the Rapide SL which is similar to the Tensor in comfort.

I don’t think that’s a noticeable improvement in comfort to make the switch from the Tensor.

OP has a medical issue and if they can’t get by with an already comfortable pad like the Tensor, chances are they’re probably not going to do well with the Either light either, which is a marginal improvement at best in comfort. UL means being as light as possible while still being comfortable, it’s not necessarily just about sacrifice, but being smart with what you choose not to take. Both the Megamat and Neoloft pack reasonably small, and maybe an extra pound is well within their carrying capacity and worth it if they can sleep soundly. The whole point of UL was to make life on the trail easier, but if the camp experience sucks then what’s the point. A pissing contest on base weight? I think you might be confusing UL with the show Naked and Afraid. Because that’s your endgame.

Second for the Megamat Ultra. It’s a big jump in comfort over any ultralight pad. Depending upon how far I’m hiking I’ll bring it over my Tensor All Season which is a decently comfortable pad in its own right.

Go with the Tensor all season. It’s a buy once, cry once type of item. The cheap pads for half the price come with very limited warranties. Nemo has a lifetime warranty, and when it comes to air mats in particular, there’s a good chance you’ll have an issue at some point that you can’t repair. Nemo replaced my mat twice over a 7 year period, once for a valve issue and the other was the baffle failure that many of their older pads had. Each time I got the updated version. To me the warranty alone is worth the extra cost, just make sure you get it from an authorized retailer. REI is really nice because you can access your purchase information as a member making any warranty claim a snap. The All Season also happens to be the best overall pad for its blend of comfort, weight, durability and warmth. It’s R value will get you through most of the year on its own, and the full year when combined w a ccf pad if you dare to camp in the middle of winter.

The Nemo is more comfortable,and its 5.6 R value is plenty warm down to around -10 or so which would mean your sleeping bag would be the bottleneck. They are releasing the Elipse soon though which is a less expensive version of the Tensor and has some impressive specs including a 6.2 R value, so if you don’t have a trip soon it might be worth waiting a little longer.

Get the all season, it’s more comfortable then the Xlite especially if you move a lot and are a side sleeper. One thing to note is that the Tensor Elite is going to be released soon in a wide version. If you are really concerned about weight that may be the way to go, but I think it will be wide mummy, not wide rectangle.

The true value of an air mattress is the warranty. Nemo replaced my tensor twice. Once for a valve issue the other due to the baffle design. Who’s helping you out if your Chinese mat fails?

Feels the same, except quieter.

I just checked myself, they're both listed as 1lb but the listed weight in grams puts the Eclipse at 20 grams heavier. That's not nothing, but considering it is in fact thicker, warmer, and cheaper, I too am wondering why you would choose the Tensor now if you had to pick between the two. I feel like a lot of people in this thread are trying to defend existing purchases.

Again, no one is telling you to get a new pad. The question is why you would choose a Tensor over the Eclipse.

One more time, I'm not telling people to buy anything. The literal point of OP's post is to ask why anyone would buy the Tensor over the Eclipse. And a bunch of people are giving reasons that only defend their existing purchase. Cool, great, enjoy your pad, but that's completely irrelevant to OP's question. "I don't need a warmer pad" is not a valid reason to choose one over the other.

I don't know what you're looking at but they're both listed as the same weight. And no one is asking you to buy a new pad.

Love my tensor all season. It checks all the boxes. Very comfortable

Currently I think the Tensor Insulated is the best choice. It's definitely more comfortable for most. Importantly, it's more reliable when it comes to product failures (baffle delamination etc.). The Therm-a-rest is certainly still good in this regard comparing to other brands but we see about 50% less incidents with the Nemo in our store.

Nemo tensor all season has a 5.4 r value, packs quite small, and weighs 16 oz which I think is certainly pretty light for that level of warmth

I would probably not pick MEC products anymore, they have dropped in quality. So MH or Nemo for a sleeping bag. And since you’re a fellow Canadian, go for the higher R value, especially since your bag only goes to -9. The Nemo tensor is a good option here.

I took delivery of a brand new Tensor All season Rectangular Reg wide yesterday. Mat only weighs in at 537g on my scales. 

I tried both and went with the Ether Light XR. It came down to what felt good. I didn’t think the baffle design on the Tensor AS was comfortable or distributed weight well and much preferred the baffling on the Ether Lite as a side/stomach sleeper. I plan on upping the R value with a Z-lite pad if necessary.

I just got back from a weeklong canoe trip in the Allagash and this one from Nemo was what I used. Awesome… comfortable, lightweight, has a bag to help you inflate the pad. https://amzn.to/4nJxOjW

I just bought the regular sized version for the same pad and I haven’t used it much but I really like it so far. Doesn’t deflate by morning at all. Super easy to inflate and I find that it packs nicely into my gossamer gear gorilla pack.