Terraventure Series

Have you tried topo athletic? It sounds like you're describing the terraventure, which I love for the reasons you described

Non goretex trail runners Topo are my jam. Big wide toe box. Altra is my second choice

Topo for the win. Altras wear out way to fast

I’ve worn Altras and Topos. My wife has some Hokas. It really depends on what fits your feet.

Hi, I sell shoes at a local gear shop close to the PCT. You need to give me more information about your feet, your size and width. Chances are your shoes are too small. I personally hiked with the Topo Terraventure and love them, and I’ve also hiked over 1000 miles on the Ultraventure. Mainly I like their durability compared to Altra and HOKA. But again, it’s whatever shoe works for your foot and you’ve given zero info on that.

I’ve gotten 500+ miles on several Topo models, though I hear Norda 001 last even longer.

Terraventures have better grip and stability. They are less cushy but have a rock plate so it balances out, unless you need the extra cushion.

Topo Terraventures. But I’d avoid the WP version unless you’re running in snow.

In general, not specific to that shoe. As the other commenter said, they fill with water and don’t drain. They also make your feet hot. I only use them in snow since the warmth is a bonus at that point and snow melt will freeze your feet.

Topos have definitely been more durable in my experience, but they do try to split the difference between a true foot shaped toe box and a traditional pointed toe box, and that can be a bit uncomfortable compared to a true foot shaped shoe. I do still find them more comfortable than traditional trail runners though. They also have better tread than altras imo, especially for mud and loose dirt or dusty ground